Since the publication of her first book, The Sole Spokesman, in , Ayesha Jalal has been Pakistan’s leading historian. Educated at. The Sole Spokesman: Jinnah, Muslim League And Demand For Pakistan ( Cambridge South Asian Studies) Cambridge Studies By Ayesha Jalal Online. Thomas R. Metcalf; ayesha jalal. The Sole Spokesman: Jinnah, the Muslim League, and the Demand for Pakistan. (Cambridge South Asian.
|Published (Last):||13 September 2010|
|PDF File Size:||4.32 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||11.34 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
Igoo Apr 15, Muslims from across the board – from all spectrums, religious and Western – responded to the colonial experience. It does not matter jala, wanted partition or not.
The Sole Spokesman has become a kind of academic orthodoxy – even if you don’t agree with it, you have to look at it. So better start eating it. Ayesha Jalal PunjabiUrdu: That is Manto’s point of view. History is about perspective and balance. If Jinnah wanted a Pakistan, then he would have allowed this, but he did not allow this because he wanted to ensure that Muslims from those provinces where they were in a minority also got something.
And just the general attitude towards Muslims. In other words, there was nothing preordained about the military’s rise to dominance. She stayed at Cambridge untilworking as a fellow of Trinity College and later as a Leverhulme Fellow. Very often the hero of one is a foe of the other and, likewise, their victories and defeats overlap. Feb 20, Tahir Ashraf rated it really liked it Shelves: AK Apr 13, It, however, gives me some insight into the mainstream historiography of the partition as well as that of Pakistan, by departing from it.
What is the use of talking about pros and cons of partition when its already done with?
The Sole Spokesman: Jinnah, the Muslim League, and the Demand for Pakistan
In foreign country all the relevant material is available,which is banned in Pakistan. No use analyzing the past but lets work to see how we can live like decent neighbours where one does not interfere in others affairs and develop friendship and build our common cultures. After reading this, i directly came down for a comment.
If you look at the media, some of the best scholars who are producing excellent work don’t get invited to speak on the media.
One of the great fallacies ayeesha those wedded to seeing history purely through the ‘great men in history’ argument is that they don’t see the context. The failure of that nationalism is not adequately acknowledged. So, truths should be revealed about the past as it may generate a hope for the future. But then he was sidelined by Gandhi and others. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.
In his book Covering Islam he talks about the nexus between the academy, the multinationals, the media and the White House. The notion that Hindus and Muslims cannot live together is only because solle extremists believes on both sides. The prosethe rich sprinkling of idiomsthe thought, the nacked truth. Then there is also the important factor of codification which has made Islam into a closed system.
Jan 10, Hasan rated it liked it.
Amjad USA Apr 12, Any centre for independent India would have to be decided upon by the Muslim majority provinces, the princely states and the Hindu majority provinces on the basis that Muslims are a nation entitled to equal treatment along with Hindus. People’s history can be written when you have some broad agreement on the narrative of your history. User Review – Flag as inappropriate It just describe the same story near to textbooks.
What do you think is the pity of Partition? You have written about jihad’s year history in Ja,al, starting with Syed Ahmad Shaheed. She knows very little about India and history and boasts lot.
Jinnah did not want Partition: Ayesha Jalal – Herald
I might have fit visually into the stereotype of me but my thoughts did not fit in, which aayesha people uncomfortable. Jun 27, Indeneri rated it did not like it Shelves: Murtaza Pracha rated it it was amazing Feb 25, Nationalism that leads to exclusionary results harps on the idioms of your own community. She is among the most prominent American academics who writes on the history of South Asia.
The bulk of her work deals with the creation of Muslim identities in modern South Asia. Centre and province Simla and the elections of This is too long.
To find a niche for yourself was not an easy thing. Well, that was clearly not what Jinnah thf in mind. It just describe the same story near to textbooks.
Open Preview See a Problem? She is also known for positing in The Sole Spokesman that the Partition of India and Pakistan was less a political necessity than a tge human tragedy and th Ayesha Jalal is a Pakistani-American historian and academic, and the Mary Richardson Professor of History at Tufts University. This book outlines the ‘Cambridge’ thesis about the formation of Pakistan developed originally by Professor Anil Seal and spokeeman into a PhD thesis by Dr. Chris rated it really liked it May 17,